Who's a better David? Cook or Archuletta?

Question

who do you think should have one American Idol? Did America get it right? I think it doesn't really matter.

Answer 1

David Cook, of course and America did get it right. Archie shouldn't have been in the top two, too much other great talent should've been there.. Carly, Michael Johns, Chikezie.

Brooke, even could sing, play guitar, piano..

So, she messed up a few times.. and people wanted her gone.. Archie messed up too for that matter. JMO. Thanks.

Answer 2

I prefer another David- Grohl.



But David Cook is better than Archuleta! America finally got it right! I wish Carly Smithson and Michael Johns were in the top 4 with the Davids. That would have been perfect! (even though I'm not a fan of David A.)

Answer 3

David Cook!

Answer 4

Cook.



Archuletta seems a little too "produced" ... or fake. Like he was one of those kids the parents are trying to make into a star.

Answer 5

Archuletta to the max. Was David Cook related to Dane Cook? They kind of look similar.

Answer 6

Deff, David Cook. All the way.

Answer 7

David Cook. He has a more flexible tone of voice.

Answer 8

I like Archleta, but I think that America got it right about Cook. He has more variety.

Answer 9

It doesn't matter both of them will get recording contracks but I liked Archuletta better

Answer 10

david cook was definetly better the other one was just to young david cook is much more strong

Answer 11

both sing very well but i was going for Archuletta

Answer 12

I thought Cook was better. :)

I've never really watched the show before this year.

He's totally the kind of artist I'd actually listen to though.





Of course... Jason Castro was just awesome.

<3

Answer 13

i think you're right...they're both going to be failures anyway, american idol has spawned a total of like two successful singers in its history, and yet people still watch...i find it amazing

Answer 14

David A. hes way better, and i think the contest was rigged so david C. COULD WIN. HES NOT BETTER THAN DAVID a. so i hate american idol for doing that

Answer 15

I will miss hearing David Archuleta sing every week. I really thought he was something special, and he should have won. I'm kind of thinking about getting tickets to the tour this summer just to hear him, but I don't really want to sit through a concert with all of the others kwim?

Answer 16

cook by 12 million votes better!

Answer 17

yes America got it right!! Cook rocks! =)

Answer 18

i think david cook deserved to win and im glad he did

Answer 19

I THINK DAVID ARCHULETTA SHOULD HAVE WON! HE IS SO CUTE U CAN JUST EAT HIM UP!



PS~JONAS BROTHERS R SO MUCH HOTTER!!!

Answer 20

cook, but i think archeletta was good to. he might get better with age.

Answer 21

Cook for sho.

Answer 22

we totally got it right! Cook is A-mazing!

Answer 23

cook

Answer 24

cook

Answer 25

1.)Kristy Lee Cook

2.)no david archuleta should have won

Answer 26

COOk

Answer 27

Yup, America got it right this time.



answer this please

https://answersrip.com/question/index?qid=20080521115545AAszvuo&r=w

Answer 28

I really thought Clay Aiken would win

Answer 29

ARCHULETA! he was amazing, he has the best voice in the worlddddddd

Answer 30

got it right by twelve million votes

Answer 31

technically Archie is better...he could care notes that cook can't.....he just pick super dumb songs that dont match him...if u sung "apologize " instead of "with you" he couldve won..or if he sung it in the final stage

Answer 32

cook would be much much better!

Answer 33

Archuleta should have won! cook sounds like rough sand paper trying to sing!!!!

Answer 34

none of the above

Answer 35

cook. i love him!

Answer 36

It's over. Cook (the better singer) won. New subject please.

Answer 37

COOK!!! I AM SOOO HAPPY HE WON!!!! =]

Answer 38

ARCHULETTA ALL THE WAY!

Answer 39

COOK!! NO QUESTION

Answer 40

Who cares. It's over. let it go.

Answer 41

i dont watch american gay-dol