I have to say not. Not only do I think its getting overrated, but beyonce needs to stay in her element. She is one of the very few female artists where being edgy & re-inveinting herself doesn't work for her. Like with Mariah Carey for example. Don't get me wrong, I love opposite genre collabo's but NOT ALL of them work (and in the video for "video phone" gaga was a bit out of her league, R&B is not her thing she looked foolish to me)